The Giver Quartet by Lois Lowry (YA Fiction)
One of my favourite authors growing up was Lois Lowry, thanks to Number the Stars and The Giver, two books our elementary school librarian read to us during our library class (shout-out to Mrs. Kozoris, who always picked the most kickass books!). I didn’t realize The Giver had sequels until they started talking about making the (apparently crappy) movie that came out last year, so I’m finally getting around to reading them now. For those who don’t know, The Giver is a dystopian young adult novel. I love me a good dystopia.
Gathering Blue was lame… pun not intended (the main character, Kira, has a bum leg and struggles to walk). I re-read The Giver first because it had been years and my memory of it was hazy, and it has held up well. Gathering Blue seemed like a lousy fanfic in comparison. It was boring, had no sense of urgency, and Kira was a big-time Mary Sue, although I did enjoy Matt, her young friend from the “slum” of her already slum-like village. I also appreciated the glimpses into the past and hints about how things ended up the way they are in these books. But it really just felt like a set-up for the next two novels. Fortunately, it was a quick read.
Good thing I liked the Matt character, considering he’s the protagonist in the third book, Messenger! This one was much better – an interesting story, some action, cool powers, mystery and intrigue, and a sad-ass ending. I couldn’t put it down and burned through it in a few hours. It wasn’t as deep or “important”-feeling as The Giver with its themes and allegory, but it was entertaining and got me hyped for the last book. Win.
Son was aight, but not particularly thrilling, despite the cover’s claim. It brought back characters and settings from the first few books, which was cool. The book is divided into three parts, and while the first two were interesting, the third part was anticlimactic. The final showdown was a little hokey, and the ending rushed. It felt like Lowry was on a deadline and had to finish the book right away, so she just slapped on an ending and then typed THE END. I would have liked to know more about the aftermath and the effects on Claire, who is the protagonist in the first two parts of the book, but instead we got a shot of her staring into the distance, liiiike… that’s it? The ambiguous “reader fills in the blanks” ending worked in The Giver, but for some reason fell flat here.
You can tell The Giver was never meant to be a quartet. It’s an excellent book on its own that is diminished somewhat by its sequels. Overall though, I was entertained, and I’m glad I finally got around to reading the series.